Are We Asking the Wrong Question About the Draft?

Description

The Draft Debate and the Meaning of Shevet Levi The conversation around drafting yeshiva students often begins with opinions. This shiur begins with Torah. Continuing the exploration of one of the most sensitive issues facing Am Yisrael, Rav Shlomo Katz and the chevra of Shirat David examine the Rambam's famous discussion of Shevet Levi and the claim that Torah learners occupy a unique role within the Jewish people. But does the Rambam actually exempt Torah learners from military service? Why doesn't he explicitly say so? Why were all the other tribes counted among those who went out to war? And what can we learn from the surprising role of Kohanim in Jewish battles throughout Tanach and Chazal? Rather than offering slogans or easy answers, this shiur uncovers the deeper roots of the debate and challenges listeners to approach the subject with humility, seriousness, and a genuine search for truth. ---------- For more Shuirim and Music from Rav Shlomo Katz, visit: https://ravshlomokatz.com Join Rav Shlomo Katz's WhatsApp Community: https://chat.whatsapp.com/KHKOhhPaeHx5Kb74WL9L9a?mode=ems_copy_t CHAPTERS 00:00 Sponsor Acknowledgments and Opening Blessings 01:02 Introducing the Sensitive Draft Topic and Its Controversy 04:05 Recap: Counting of Am Yisrael and Shevet Levi 06:43 Rambam on Learners' Exemption from Military Service 09:14 Clarifying Rambam's Language – Questions from the Class 23:22 Kohanim Participation in Biblical Wars 25:37 Pachad Reality: Why Kohanim Couldn't Fight 26:41 Who Can Claim Levi Status More Than a Kohen? 28:02 Proofs That Kohanim Actually Served in Battle 30:11 The Halachic Question of Kohen with Yefat Toar 34:15 Modern Tzahal: Non-Combat Soldiers and Kohen Issues 44:19 Closing Thoughts and Ongoing Questions #israeldraft #israeldraftingorthodox #israeldraftprotest #israelidraft #israelabanikandadraft #israelidraftdodgers #israelultraorthodoxdraft #israeldraftand